DIRECTED BY : VINCENTE MINELLI
STARRING: JUDY GARLAND (and a long red wig) and MARGARET O'BRIEN
It had been a few years since I'd seen this movie so, courtesy my dvr, I caught it again. Everyone knows me as an avid fan of musicals and this one meets most of my requirements. It's got a few decent songs, gorgeous costumes, and vivid technicolor that is hard to beat. It also has a credible lead in Judy Garland and her outrageous pipes. But it has its weakneses too.
The 'story' is really more of a 'tableau', if you will. A random segmentation of pretty family moments and mishaps. The Smith family is an All-American family with a strong attachment to each other and their city, Saint Louis. Leon Ames and Mary Astor play the Patriarch and Matriarch of this modern family and they do it well. The father is traditionally gruff and the mother, quite predictably, dotes upon him. There is also a wise old grandfather, a snippety maid, and some youngsters of various heights. Tootie is the youngest. Agnes is her slight elder. Alonzo Jr is a grown son mooching off the folks (well, he *IS*) and the two oldest daughters, Rose and Esther, seem to be the veritable 'glue' of the clan. Rose is pining for a distant love and Ester for the boy next door. That's about it. Nothing really happens to this family and that's okay. We don't really want anything to marr the Norman Rockwell world they live in. But neither does it make for the most exhiliarating of films.
Judy Garland was considered a tour de force of American entertainment and I guess she was. I'm personally not that big a fan. Her skinny ankles get on my nerves (probably because they remind me of my own) and I find her pretty unattractive. Also, her voice-while undeniably powerful-doesnt strike me as particularly pretty (most of the time). That said, the long wig and pretty clothes definitely show her off her to her best advantage and 'The Trolley Song' is one of the great musical moments of film-one song that truly works w/ her type of vocal. However, I believe that Margaret O'Brien was one of the best child actors of her day, and its her performance as michievous and death-obsessed Tootie, that stands out in this movie. She actually outshines all of her adult co-stars, hamming it up while at the same time not visibly attempting to do so. There's a darling little number where she and Garland sing together that is especially memorable. I've always enjoyed the voluminous nightgown O'Brien is wearing, which tried so vainly to swallow her up, throughout the performance. The number is so charming that one almost forgets how deserving the kid is of a good spanking most of the time. I mean come ON. What parents are going to fawn like that over a child that has just caused a major trolly accident by playing a prank? *chuckle*
The rest of the cast just kind of lays there. Tom Drake as the elusive John Truett-boy next door extroardinaire- is hardly the intellectual match for our heroine. Esther's infatuation with him is purely physical, if you ask me. But that's her business. Harry Davenport and Marjorie Main are always a joy but little is done w/ their characters that allows their respective talents to show thru. They're simply 'accessories' that add some spunk and sass to this bluntly traditional family.
Minelli did a lovely job w/ the direction. It has the look of the era while somehow remaining modern, and the colors, as I said before, are fantastic. It makes the movie fun to watch in spite of the insipid songs and bland performances.
This movie is now being touted as a 'Christmas movie', in spite of the very minimal amount of screentime that the actual holiday has. Judy Garland singing 'Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas' is very pretty and of course the resolution of family difficulties in the midst of said holiday is bound to be satisfying to the celebrating public. To me, it just came off as a bit forced and schmaltzy. But happy endings don't always have to be perfect to be satisfying. And it was still that.
My rating: 7/10
Style Factor: I enjoy seeing Garland's features being 'softened' by the large forward roll bang that she sports throughout the film. Also, some of the costumes are really amazing, especially when coupled with the gorgeous colors in this movie. All in all, it is on par with other Minelli films but not, by any means, his best-in terms of 'style'.
Style Scor: 7/10
7 comments:
One of my favorite films. I watched my VHS copy so many times as a kid it wore out. Lovely review! :)
This is one of my favorite movies but you brought some aspects of the movie to my attention that I have not thought of before. Such as Alonzo, Jr. mooching off of his family. You are so right! LOL!
I love it for the exact reason that you only like it. I love that it's just a sweet little year in the life of this family with no real drama, climax, or trial. This is in my top 5 movies. I can quote the whole thing from beginning to end. 10/10 for me.
Karen, I have a large assortment of favorite films that are mostly character studies as well. It just depends on how it effects you as a person, I guess. Most people don't understand why I watch The Accidental Tourist repeatedly...but I absolutely love watching those characters relate and that is the draw, for me. So I totally understand where you're coming from.
OMG, I LOVE The Trolley Song! It has been a while since I've watched this movie! BTW, I nominated you for a Beautiful Blogger Award. Oh, and I just finished watching your Betty Boop video - lovely as always!, xoxo, Tamara
http://brunetteandpink.blogspot.com/2010/01/beautiful-blogger-award-for-brunette.html
One of my faves~ I believe you're right about O'Brien, she was a show stealer. Loved her escapades!
I myself am a huge Judy Garland fan. I went up and down the walk of stars in Hollywood just to find her star (unfortunatly it's infront of the Mcdonalds a block away of the Chinese Theater). I even taught my daughter how to play the trolly song on her keyboard :) But anyway, this movie is number 3 on my top five Judy movie list. Good review :)
Post a Comment